Degeler ConsultingStrategy.
All insights
By Felix Degeler · Founder & CEO3 min read

Why we threw out a tool that looked perfect on paper

A tool with perfect integration is worthless if it slows you down day-to-day. Why we switched time tracking from everhour to Toggl, and what that says about tool decisions.

Felix Degeler in a DC hoodie, on the phone outdoors.

Key takeaways

  • A tool with perfect integration is worthless if the team avoids it day-to-day.
  • Usability, clear reports and a scalable setup beat the longest feature list.
  • Sunk cost is no argument: if a tool slows you down, it goes.

We threw out our time-tracking tool even though it integrated perfectly with Notion. On paper everhour was ideal. In daily use it was too expensive, too inflexible and unpleasant for the team to operate. So out it went.

Integration on paper doesn't count

Many tool decisions are made on feature lists and integration logos. That's exactly the trap. What counts isn't what a tool can do, but whether the team happily uses it every day.

everhour had the prettier Notion connection. Toggl had the better usability, clearer reports, a usable mobile app and a setup that scales with projects and automations. In daily use the second one wins.

Throwing out a tool is a strength, not a failure

Sticking with a tool just because you introduced it is more expensive than switching. Sunk cost is not an argument. If a tool slows you down, it goes, even if the migration stings briefly.

We bring exactly this pragmatic tool view into IT and process projects: not the tool with the most features, but the one your team actually uses.

The same “usability first” stance sits in the products we help build ourselves, like the Kitale platform.

DC illustration: a crossed-out block next to an orange block with a swap arrow, the better tool wins.

Frequently asked

Why did you switch from everhour to Toggl?
everhour had the nicer Notion integration but was too expensive and inflexible in daily use. Toggl wins on usability, clearer reports, a good mobile app and a setup that scales with projects and automations.
How should you choose a software tool?
Not by the feature list but by daily use. The deciding question is whether the team uses the tool happily and reliably. A tool that slows you down day-to-day costs more than it saves.
ShareWhatsApp
30 minutes, no commitment

Let's justtalk.

You'll leave with an honest read you can actually use internally – whether we end up working together or respectfully part ways. No pitches. No pressure.